Trace Primal Spark auto-comment failure against Framework address
This commit is contained in:
@@ -315,3 +315,37 @@ a hypothesis, not a confirmed root cause. Asked which wallets fail and whether
|
||||
an empty comment also fails. Need that result before selecting a code fix.
|
||||
The service controls the advertised limit; changing local Receive text or QR
|
||||
cannot raise it for other wallets.
|
||||
|
||||
### Primal Spark: automatic recipient note exceeds the address limit
|
||||
|
||||
User clarified that no comment was entered and the sender is Primal Spark.
|
||||
Checked Framework's management journal over the preceding 20 minutes: no
|
||||
comment-length errors, service active, and zero pending Minibits claims. Recent
|
||||
claim polling connected to and disconnected from the relay normally. Historical
|
||||
seed-authentication failures preceded the successful setup already documented.
|
||||
|
||||
The live address's Minibits `text/plain` description is **101 ASCII characters**,
|
||||
while `commentAllowed` is **100**. Description template (address redacted):
|
||||
`Pay to [ADDRESS] with Lightning. Receiver will receive ecash into Minibits Wallet.`
|
||||
|
||||
Primal Android source at `36939db97213e7f8eeefaa4adaf125d839fc662e`:
|
||||
- `WalletTextParserImpl.handleLnUrlText` assigns the parsed description to
|
||||
`DraftTx.noteRecipient`, including for Lightning-address input.
|
||||
- `TransactionEditor` initializes its editable recipient note from that value.
|
||||
- `SparkWalletServiceImpl` passes it untrimmed to `PrepareLnurlPayRequest.comment`.
|
||||
- Breez Spark source at `8bb38ec292a590907360c4e7f2a4134b8f09de9e`,
|
||||
`common/src/lnurl/pay.rs::validate_user_input`, rejects a comment exceeding the
|
||||
limit with the exact reported error before requesting the callback.
|
||||
|
||||
This identifies a concrete compatibility failure: the address description can
|
||||
become an automatic over-limit comment without the sender typing anything.
|
||||
The installed Primal platform/version and its actual request have not been
|
||||
captured, so final confirmation requires retrying after explicitly clearing the
|
||||
prefilled recipient note. Node logs alone cannot show sender-side validation
|
||||
or requests to the external Minibits callback.
|
||||
|
||||
Durable upstream correction: Primal should keep receiver metadata separate from
|
||||
the sender's comment and enforce the limit on actual user comments. Minibits can
|
||||
also shorten its description or raise its advertised comment limit. Archy does
|
||||
not serve this external LNURL metadata; do not rename an existing wallet address,
|
||||
rotate its seed, or claim that a local dashboard edit fixes this sender behavior.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user