Bug surfaced live on .228 2026-05-02 — every backend Quadlet unit
(lnd, electrumx, fedimint, btcpay-server, mempool-api, bitcoin-knots)
hit systemd's default 90s start timeout because Notify=healthy makes
systemctl wait for the first green health probe, but
HealthInterval=30s × HealthRetries=3 = 90s minimum even on a healthy
service. Race: timeout fires the moment the third probe MIGHT succeed.
Result was three different post-states (inactive+running, failed+missing,
inactive+stopped) depending on whether systemd's ExecStopPost ran
podman rm before the orchestrator's adoption logic re-grabbed the
container.
Fix: when health is set, render TimeoutStartSec=600 (10 minutes) into
[Service]. Long enough for slow-starting backends (electrumx index
replay, lnd wallet unlock) without being so long that a truly stuck
unit hangs forever. Companions stay unchanged (no health → no override,
default 90s applies).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two bugs surfaced by the first real-node validation of Phase 3.2-3.4
on .228 (2026-05-02), both caught before flipping the default.
Bug 1 — translate_health_check double-prefixed http://. Manifests in
the wild carry the scheme inside the endpoint string ("http://localhost:8175"),
and we were prepending another http:// unconditionally. Result on .228:
every backend HealthCmd read `curl -fsS -m 5 http://http://localhost...`,
every probe failed, fedimint hit a 14-restart loop. Now we accept either
form and skip appending hc.path when the endpoint already carries one.
Regression test asserts no double-prefix and that an in-endpoint path
is honoured.
Bug 2 — Phase 3.3 migration ran for UI companions (bitcoin-ui /
electrs-ui / lnd-ui) that have shipped via Quadlet since v1.7.41.
Migration tore down the running companion + raced companion.rs render,
producing "Phase 3.3: re-install archy-bitcoin-ui via Quadlet" reconcile
errors and leaving archy-bitcoin-ui down. Companions now short-circuit
out of migrate_to_quadlet_if_needed before any IO. Also: when try_exists
returns Err for an unrelated reason (permissions, EIO), we now skip
migration instead of treating "I can't tell" as "go ahead and migrate" —
migrating on top of a possibly-existing unit is destructive.
What this does not fix yet:
* the orchestrator's reconciler iterating every manifest in
/opt/archipelago/apps/, not just installed apps. Pre-existing
behavior (also affects the legacy path) — separate scope.
* fedimint /data UID mismatch surfaced when Quadlet started fedimint
fresh. Likely orthogonal — defer.
* no rollback when install_via_quadlet fails after a remove_container.
Tracked as Phase 3.3.1 — defer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
QuadletUnit gains an optional HealthSpec; from_manifest translates the
manifest's health_check (tcp/http/cmd) into a HealthCmd= directive and
emits Notify=healthy alongside it. systemctl start <unit>.service then
blocks until the container's first green probe — eliminating the
"container up but RPC not ready" race the orchestrator currently papers
over with post-start polling.
Translation policy:
* tcp, endpoint "host:port" -> nc -z host port
* http, endpoint "host:port", path -> curl -fsS -m 5 http://endpoint<path>
* cmd, endpoint "<shell command>" -> verbatim
* unknown type / malformed endpoint -> None (skip Notify=healthy rather
than emit a HealthCmd that hangs the unit start forever)
Companion units leave health: None and remain byte-identical to before
this PR — the renderer only emits the Health* / Notify= block when set.
+4 quadlet unit tests (19 total). Dropped a never-used test setter that
was generating a dead_code warning.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
prod_orchestrator::install_fresh now branches on the new
Config::use_quadlet_backends flag (default false):
* off (today's production behavior) — unchanged: runtime.create_container
+ start_container, container parented under archipelago.service's
cgroup, FM3 cascade SIGKILL on every archipelago restart.
* on — install_via_quadlet renders the manifest as a Quadlet unit via
QuadletUnit::from_manifest, writes it atomically into
~/.config/containers/systemd/, calls daemon-reload, and starts the
generated <name>.service. Container ends up under user.slice — no
more cgroup parented under archipelago, so archipelago restarts
don't touch the container's lifetime.
Default off so this commit is structurally safe to ship: nothing
changes at runtime until an operator opts in. Flip the default once
tests/lifecycle/run-20x.sh has gone green against the new path on
.228 + .198 (the v1.7.52 release gate).
Plumbing:
* config.rs — `use_quadlet_backends: bool` w/ Default false
* prod_orchestrator.rs — flag stored on the struct, threaded through
new(), with set_use_quadlet_backends(bool) test setter
* prod_orchestrator.rs — install_via_quadlet helper
* dropped the Phase-3.1 #[allow(dead_code)] markers on from_manifest /
parse_memory_mib / RestartPolicy::OnFailure now that the call path
exists; if a future revert removes the wiring, the warnings come back.
Tests: 624 passing, cargo check clean (0 warnings). Existing companion
behavior unaffected — render_skips_backend_directives_when_default
still passes byte-equal to before quadlet.rs grew the new fields.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The QuadletUnit struct now covers everything a backend manifest needs
(ports, environment, devices, add_hosts, entrypoint+command, read-only
root, no_new_privileges, cpu_quota, restart policy choice). Adds
QuadletUnit::from_manifest(&AppManifest, name) that translates a parsed
manifest into a unit, plus parse_memory_mib for "1g"/"512m"/raw-MiB
forms. The renderer skips empty/false directives so existing companion
units render byte-identically — no behavior change for shipping
companions; the backend renderer is dead code until Phase 3.2 wires it
into the orchestrator.
Eight new unit tests cover:
* parse_memory_mib forms (1024, 512m, 2g, garbage)
* shell_join quoting (whitespace, embedded quotes)
* RestartPolicy → systemd string mapping
* render emits backend directives when set
* render skips them when defaulted (companion regression gate)
* from_manifest happy path on a bitcoin-knots-shaped manifest
* from_manifest read-only volume detection
* from_manifest tmpfs filtering
* end-to-end manifest → render bytes assertion
Tests: 615 → 624 (+9 net; one pre-existing parse_memory_mib path was
implicitly covered before but is now explicit). Cargo warnings: 0.
`from_manifest`, `parse_memory_mib`, and `RestartPolicy::OnFailure` are
marked allow(dead_code) with explicit references to Phase 3.2 — if
3.2 doesn't wire them, the dead-code warning resurfaces.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Companion UI containers (archy-bitcoin-ui, archy-lnd-ui,
archy-electrs-ui) used to be launched as fire-and-forget tokio::spawn
blocks from install.rs. If archipelago crashed mid-spawn or the
container's cgroup was reaped, companions vanished from podman ps -a
and only a manual rm/run could bring them back (the .228 incident).
Now each companion is rendered as a Quadlet .container unit under
~/.config/containers/systemd/, daemon-reloaded, and started via
systemctl --user. systemd owns supervision from that point on:
- archipelago can crash, restart, or be uninstalled without touching
any companion.
- Quadlet's Restart=always + RestartSec=10 handles container exits.
- A 30s reconcile tick in boot_reconciler enumerates expected
companion units and re-installs any whose unit file or service
vanished — defense-in-depth against external tampering.
New module layout:
- container/quadlet.rs: pure unit renderer + atomic write_if_changed
+ systemctl helpers (daemon_reload_user / enable_now / disable_remove
/ is_active). 6 unit tests, no I/O in the renderer.
- container/companion.rs: per-app companion specs, install/remove/
reconcile, image presence (build local first, fall back to insecure
registry only via image_uses_insecure_registry whitelist). 2 tests.
install.rs handle_package_install now ends with a single call to
companion::install_for(package_id), replacing 287 lines of spawn-and-
hope shellouts plus a ~120-line nginx auth-injector helper that worked
around per-node RPC password baking. The helper is gone too — the
pre-start hook renders the per-node nginx.conf to /var/lib/archipelago/
bitcoin-ui/nginx.conf and the Quadlet unit bind-mounts it read-only.
runtime.rs handle_package_uninstall now disables companions before
the container rm loop. Otherwise systemd's Restart=always would
respawn each companion within ~10s of removal.
Tests: 53 container tests pass, including 6 quadlet renderer tests
(host network, bridge network, capability set, atomic write idempotence)
and 2 companion specs (per-app companion lookup, build_unit shape).
boot_reconciler tests gain a #[cfg(test)] without_companion_stage()
flag so the paused-clock fixtures don't race the real systemctl I/O.
A bats regression test (companion-survives-archipelago-restart.bats,
gated on ARCHY_ALLOW_DESTRUCTIVE=1) asserts the .228 failure mode
cannot recur: every installed companion has a unit file, services
stay active across systemctl --user restart archipelago, and a
deleted unit file is recreated within one reconcile tick.
Net delta: +941 / -363, but the +941 is mostly tests (~440 lines)
and the new declarative layer; the imperative tokio::spawn block and
its nginx-auth helper are gone, removing two failure classes
(orphan companions on archipelago crash, and post-start exec races
under tightly-confined cgroups) that previously needed manual SSH
recovery.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
